Page 1 of 2

Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2018 10:53 pm
by Ant428
Good Afternoon, (or morning)

I am making an awning frame out of 1 1/2" aluminum square tubing 1/8" wall. When I make the butt joints, the metal flows fine and shiny , but when I do the tee joint, or fillet weld, I cannot get the metal to flow. In fact, I can't get a proper puddle going!. Any ideas? Its like I can't break through the barrier or oxidation layer???

Specs
140 amps AC
70%en
120 freq
#7 gas lens with 3/32 tungsten
3/32 filler rod
25CFH Argon 100%

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2018 11:54 pm
by MinnesotaDave
More amps, don't be timid - aluminum loves amps.

Make sure stickout is far enough to get a good tight arc to get puddle started.

Get on the power quickly, timid will cause you problems.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2018 7:09 am
by Ant428
MinnesotaDave wrote:More amps, don't be timid - aluminum loves amps.

Make sure stickout is far enough to get a good tight arc to get puddle started.

Get on the power quickly, timid will cause you problems.
I'm full throttle right away, and a tight arc. I'm right in there.
I'm wondering if I didn't clean it properly.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2018 7:59 am
by cj737
How high are your amps? For what you’re describing, I’d be above 170 to get my puddle, and filling it with 1/8” rod.

Edit: Sorry, didn’t see your settings. So, crank up your amps.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2018 8:57 am
by Ant428
cj737 wrote:How high are your amps? For what you’re describing, I’d be above 170 to get my puddle, and filling it with 1/8” rod.

Edit: Sorry, didn’t see your settings. So, crank up your amps.
But the charts call for 130-150 for 1/8 wall. Why so high?
What would be your cleaning process for tubing?

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2018 9:16 am
by MinnesotaDave
Ant428 wrote:
MinnesotaDave wrote:More amps, don't be timid - aluminum loves amps.

Make sure stickout is far enough to get a good tight arc to get puddle started.

Get on the power quickly, timid will cause you problems.
I'm full throttle right away, and a tight arc. I'm right in there.
I'm wondering if I didn't clean it properly.
Like I said, more amps.

No matter what charts say, if it doesn't make a clear shiny puddle in 3 seconds or less at full pedal, increase amps. Back off as needed while you weld.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2018 9:54 am
by cj737
Ant428 wrote:
cj737 wrote:How high are your amps? For what you’re describing, I’d be above 170 to get my puddle, and filling it with 1/8” rod.

Edit: Sorry, didn’t see your settings. So, crank up your amps.
But the charts call for 130-150 for 1/8 wall. Why so high?
What would be your cleaning process for tubing?
Charts are typically based upon flat welds, not joints and fillets and vertical needs. Cleaning for me depends upon material condition and requirement. Sometimes, I don’t even clean the material but just adjust my Balance and crank on it. :o

I’ve never encountered the material cleanliness being the cause of not getting a puddle except for rust and poor ground connections. Rust is obviously not an issue with ally. Crank the byatch up and get your arc length right. It will weld.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2018 7:01 pm
by MinnesotaDave
cj737 wrote: Charts are typically based upon flat welds, not joints and fillets and vertical needs. Cleaning for me depends upon material condition and requirement. Sometimes, I don’t even clean the material but just adjust my Balance and crank on it. :o

I’ve never encountered the material cleanliness being the cause of not getting a puddle except for rust and poor ground connections. Rust is obviously not an issue with ally. Crank the byatch up and get your arc length right. It will weld.
Yep, what he said ^^^

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Fri Jun 08, 2018 11:24 pm
by Metal_pig2001
You may well be getting a different gas coverage when you are doing the other joint types.
Can you organise some “dams” from aluminum foil to help contsin the argon?
What are you “aiming” the arc at?

Regards

Ralph

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Sun Jun 10, 2018 12:43 pm
by Warrenh
The max amps setting on the machine I use is 403-amps. That is where my machine stays when I weld aluminum regardless of thickness. My advice is to believe what you see in the puddle and dont worry about amp charts. You have the peddle to control the amps.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Sun Jun 10, 2018 3:24 pm
by Ant428
Metal_pig2001 wrote:You may well be getting a different gas coverage when you are doing the other joint types.
Can you organise some “dams” from aluminum foil to help contsin the argon?
What are you “aiming” the arc at?

Regards

Ralph
I aim the arch right into the joint , where the two pieces meet. Maybe a little bit more on the bottom piece.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Sun Jun 10, 2018 5:48 pm
by motox
Warren
couldn't agree more. turn it up and learn to read the puddle, thats
why you have a foot pedal.
craig

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Sun Jun 10, 2018 8:59 pm
by Ant428
motox wrote:Warren
couldn't agree more. turn it up and learn to read the puddle, thats
why you have a foot pedal.
craig
I agree, but I was concerned that I was doing something wrong because I feel like 150 amps should be enough for a fillet weld on 1/8. HOWEVER....it was square tuning mitered, so the wall at the mitere is more than 1/8 at the joint. That could be why more amps are required.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Sun Jun 10, 2018 9:05 pm
by MinnesotaDave
Ant428 wrote:
motox wrote:Warren
couldn't agree more. turn it up and learn to read the puddle, thats
why you have a foot pedal.
craig
I agree, but I was concerned that I was doing something wrong because I feel like 150 amps should be enough for a fillet weld on 1/8. HOWEVER....it was square tuning mitered, so the wall at the mitere is more than 1/8 at the joint. That could be why more amps are required.
You were doing something wrong...not enough amps.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Mon Jun 11, 2018 7:42 am
by Ant428
MinnesotaDave wrote:
Ant428 wrote:
motox wrote:Warren
couldn't agree more. turn it up and learn to read the puddle, thats
why you have a foot pedal.
craig
I agree, but I was concerned that I was doing something wrong because I feel like 150 amps should be enough for a fillet weld on 1/8. HOWEVER....it was square tuning mitered, so the wall at the mitere is more than 1/8 at the joint. That could be why more amps are required.
You were doing something wrong...not enough amps.
Lol. Tú ché

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Mon Jun 11, 2018 8:22 am
by motox
Specs
140 amps AC
70%en
120 freq
#7 gas lens with 3/32 tungsten
3/32 filler rod
25CFH Argon 100%

what machine?

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Mon Jun 11, 2018 9:41 am
by cj737
Ant428 wrote:
Ant428 wrote:
motox wrote:Warren
couldn't agree more. turn it up and learn to read the puddle, thats
why you have a foot pedal.
craig
I agree, but I was concerned that I was doing something wrong because I feel like 150 amps should be enough for a fillet weld on 1/8. HOWEVER....it was square tuning mitered, so the wall at the mitere is more than 1/8 at the joint. That could be why more amps are required.

Turn your machine up to 180 amps, smash the pedal, get your puddle, and then taper off as needed. Setting your machine at your suspected max amps deprives of you of the ability to add or subtract heat as you go. This limits your ability to adapt while welding.

The only time I set a max and use full pedal is with pulse set on DC TIG. For ally, I always set it 20-25% higher than I know I'll need, so I use less pedal and can finesse the weld as required.

Now mash the darn thing already you Chicken Little! :lol: ;)

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jun 28, 2018 8:30 pm
by BillE.Dee
I am building a bench rest out of aluminum tubing (3x3x1/8). Sometimes I can get the puddle going and sometimes I can't. IF I move to a center area of the tubing, I can weld like a pro...I get to 2 tubes together and it looks like the pro left dodge and took a crash course in demolition. I grab a practice piece (thicker) and have at it with decent results. Also, when I get the heat up (must be too much) I can't get the filler rod to the puddle - it melts before I get there. Suggestions are definitely welcomed.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jun 28, 2018 11:25 pm
by cj737
BillE.Dee wrote:I am building a bench rest out of aluminum tubing (3x3x1/8). Sometimes I can get the puddle going and sometimes I can't. IF I move to a center area of the tubing, I can weld like a pro...I get to 2 tubes together and it looks like the pro left dodge and took a crash course in demolition. I grab a practice piece (thicker) and have at it with decent results. Also, when I get the heat up (must be too much) I can't get the filler rod to the puddle - it melts before I get there. Suggestions are definitely welcomed.
Possibly, your tungsten is too far away from the surface when welding into a fillet. Often you need to extend farther, or, reduce the cup size to allow you to tuck in tighter. Filler melting back before getting to the puddle screams "long arc". The farther you are away from the puddle with the cup, the wider the heat zone, the greater the likelihood of melting your filler.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Wed Jul 04, 2018 2:55 pm
by BillE.Dee
Thanks, CJ, I'll give that a try. Some of my welds are ok and some of them look like bird droppings are art form. Surely learning some new syllables...and it isn't yeehaw.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Wed Jul 04, 2018 9:54 pm
by Ant428
BillE.Dee wrote:I am building a bench rest out of aluminum tubing (3x3x1/8). Sometimes I can get the puddle going and sometimes I can't. IF I move to a center area of the tubing, I can weld like a pro...I get to 2 tubes together and it looks like the pro left dodge and took a crash course in demolition. I grab a practice piece (thicker) and have at it with decent results. Also, when I get the heat up (must be too much) I can't get the filler rod to the puddle - it melts before I get there. Suggestions are definitely welcomed.
I do notice I cant get a proper puddle if I dont clean the material properly.
Do make sure your using enough amps and a tight arc. AL can be tough.

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jul 05, 2018 3:49 pm
by BillE.Dee
I for sure notice that if I forget to clean, clean, clean .. I get terrible bird art. I get bird art anyway. Not sure when to use bigger cups or more gas...usually at 17-20cfh...and a #7 cup... :ugeek:

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jul 05, 2018 3:51 pm
by BillE.Dee
I'm getting SO confused ... like spending 3 days on a highway cloverleaf. :evil:

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Thu Jul 05, 2018 6:34 pm
by motox
have you welded a lot of mild steel?
craig

Re: Aluminum Square Tubing Problem

Posted: Mon Jul 09, 2018 6:46 am
by BillE.Dee
I have welded steel, not a LOT but can get it done. This aluminum thing is just winding me up a little bit. I'll get a decent weld, have one of the kids call me or come talk to me and when I get back at it ... bird art or if I move to a different area of the project ... bird art, til I get running. Who the hell changes the environment when I'm not looking anyway ???