Page 1 of 1

amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2014 10:52 pm
by janjon
Hello, noob here! Any thoughts on amperage settings for welding 4130 tube, coped joints, (roll cage) .083 wall cage to .056 wall support. Using Diversion 180, ER70-S6, E-3 tungsten. Having hell with blowing holes in either the thinner-wall 1-1/2" .056, or the edges of the 1-5/8" .083, which is notched to fit over the .056. Dealing with less than perfect fits, as well, in some places.
I have been attempting mid 70 settings.

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2014 6:39 am
by jumpinjackflash
I don't know much about welding....but my learning curve on .035" wall tube was lot different that what I thought. If it were me doing the cage...I would set the amps to 130 or so. Long needle pointed tungsten with a gas lens and 20 cfh. Puddle up on the thicker wall tube to start. Make a couple practice joints...very close fit ups are needed for nice welds. No gaps or mill scale allowed. Clean with acetone before tacking up....I will try and find some drops and put a junction together today. I would rather use ER70s-2....seeing as you are giving the weld area good cleaning...
But that's just how I would go at it....YMMV

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2014 7:21 am
by coldman
130amps is way too high for these joints. I think you are close to where you need to be, maybe some method tweeking. Others with much more experience with these joints will be along shortly and give you the best advice.

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2014 9:15 am
by Mike
Welcome to the forum janjon.

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2014 10:25 am
by Savvy
I'm no expert here but I do listen pretty well. You said you're blowing through the thin or burning off the thick edge. Both lead to the assumption that you're either too hot or dragging your feet running the bead. Either way your description sounds like too much heat build up. I know the Diversion doesn't have all the toys that other welders may have but I'd try keeping the settings as-is and moving faster... or dropping 5amps or so and giving it another go. Watch your heat and adjust accordingly. Maybe work on that fit-up a bit more to help keep what you're welding a consistent challenge instead of running into obsticles as you go along.

Let us know what you find out either way. A pic of what you're dealing with and what's happening could help us see what the problem is as well. Keep at it brother, where there is a will, there is a way. ;)

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2014 12:22 pm
by VooDoo
i might try one size bigger fillerrod to help "cool" down the budle down while welding, i find it helpful if there is gaps. Small gap = small filler = nice looking. Big gap - too small filler = hard to make it look like there was no gap

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2014 1:24 pm
by Cricket
For me pulsing worked well on 0.032 stainless. It took a while to fugure out the settings and get use to it though.

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2014 2:43 pm
by Savvy
Cricket wrote:For me pulsing worked well on 0.032 stainless. It took a while to fugure out the settings and get use to it though.
His Diversion doesn't have it unfortunately. Nothing but a amperage knob. :(

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Tue Apr 22, 2014 4:44 pm
by Oscar
You could try "manual" pulse with the foot pedal. I know it's not the same as getting an instantaneous current change with actual pulse capabilities, but you could mimick it as best as you can. If it's a tight space you'll need a long taper on the tungsten, down to a needle point. Get as thin of a filler as you can get, and have it ready to dab it into the thinner side of the joint to absorb the heat once it starts to puddle.

I know, I know....easier said than done. I myself am still practicing this. If the pieces are relatively small/short, then you have to be careful with heat saturation. I myself have blown through thin walled pieces because of too much overall heat, which seems to be what you're dealing with. Let them cool, and try manually pulsing them with just enough amperage so that they puddle only at the "end" of the pedal movement, if that makes any sense.

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Sun Apr 27, 2014 8:30 am
by jumpinjackflash
Here is a pic of the rear wing attach tube that was out of square and too close to the front tube as far as being correct for wing spar placement. It has bolt on wing spars....the bolt centerlines had to be as close to the lift strut bolt center line as humanly possible. I welded the tube as an assembly on the table then to the fuselage. Both side are 90 deg. true with respect of everything else. Bolt through tube is 7/16" x .078" wall and the main tube is 1" x .035" wall. Machine set to 125 amps. Thanks to all here who have helped more than anything it was no problems. Tacked up several places and took a couple of evenings to get things where they needed to be and a no gap fit up. It did not clock on me...that was my biggest fear. I guess with my learning the foot pedal I like some overhead power to get a puddle faster and back off to carry on. It helps me to keep from putting so much heat on the thin tube. But that is just my strange way. Super tight fit up really helps with different thickness tube....I mean reamer in the mill kind of fit. I found I can run a nice tight bead with no worry of blowing out. Helped me anyway... learning to fit parts tight and clean everything 3 times. :D

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Sun Apr 27, 2014 11:45 am
by MinnesotaDave
janjon wrote:Hello, noob here! Any thoughts on amperage settings for welding 4130 tube, coped joints, (roll cage) .083 wall cage to .056 wall support. Using Diversion 180, ER70-S6, E-3 tungsten. Having hell with blowing holes in either the thinner-wall 1-1/2" .056, or the edges of the 1-5/8" .083, which is notched to fit over the .056. Dealing with less than perfect fits, as well, in some places.
I have been attempting mid 70 settings.
Some questions,
noob to this forum or to tig welding?
Can you tig perfectly on straight metal in all positions? If not, tubing is going to make you nuts.
"Cage to ...wall support" - are you building a roll cage for something?

Advice,
The thinner the metal you work with, the more critical the fit-up.
Get the joint perfect, practice on scrap both your fitting and your welding.

Re: amperage selection with differing walls

Posted: Mon Apr 28, 2014 7:45 am
by zank
Do you have a foot pedal?